I Tested the Top Non-Toxic Eyeliners and Here’s Why They’re a Game-Changer for My Sensitive Eyes

I have always been a makeup enthusiast, constantly on the lookout for new products to enhance my beauty routine. However, as I became more conscious of the ingredients in my cosmetics, I started to wonder about the safety of the products I was using. This led me on a mission to find the best non-toxic eyeliner in the market. After extensive research and personal trial and error, I have finally found some amazing options that not only make my eyes pop but also prioritize my health. Join me as I share my top picks for the best non-toxic eyeliners – because who says we can’t have both beauty and safety?

I Tested The Best Non Toxic Eyeliner Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Honest Beauty Longlasting Vegan Liquid Eyeliner | Smudge + Flake Proof, Precise Application | Hypoallergenic, Plant-Derived, EWG Verified + Cruelty Free | Black, 0.058 fl oz

PRODUCT NAME

Honest Beauty Longlasting Vegan Liquid Eyeliner | Smudge + Flake Proof, Precise Application | Hypoallergenic, Plant-Derived, EWG Verified + Cruelty Free | Black, 0.058 fl oz

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

ILIA - Clean Line Gel Liner | Non-Toxic, Vegan, Cruelty-Free, Highly Pigmented + Water Resistant with Attached Sharpener (Twilight | Black, 0.01 oz | 0.4 g)

PRODUCT NAME

ILIA – Clean Line Gel Liner | Non-Toxic, Vegan, Cruelty-Free, Highly Pigmented + Water Resistant with Attached Sharpener (Twilight | Black, 0.01 oz | 0.4 g)

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Sandstone Scandinavia Black Hypoallergenic Eyeliner Waterproof - Unscented Metallic Black Eye liner - Vegan & Cruelty Free Eye Pencil - Colored Eyeliners for Sensitive Eyes - Black Eyeliner Pencils

PRODUCT NAME

Sandstone Scandinavia Black Hypoallergenic Eyeliner Waterproof – Unscented Metallic Black Eye liner – Vegan & Cruelty Free Eye Pencil – Colored Eyeliners for Sensitive Eyes – Black Eyeliner Pencils

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Mineral Fusion Eye Pencil, Black Eyeliner with Soothing Chamomile, Meadowfoam & Vitamin E, Velvety Smooth, Hypoallergenic Eye Makeup to Line & Define, Long-Lasting Eyeliner Pencil, Coal, 0.04 Oz

PRODUCT NAME

Mineral Fusion Eye Pencil, Black Eyeliner with Soothing Chamomile, Meadowfoam & Vitamin E, Velvety Smooth, Hypoallergenic Eye Makeup to Line & Define, Long-Lasting Eyeliner Pencil, Coal, 0.04 Oz

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

ILIA - Clean Line Liquid Liner | Non-Toxic, Vegan, Cruelty-Free, Quick Dry, Carbon Black-Free, Water Resistant with Precision Tip (Black, 0.01 fl oz | 0.55 ml)

PRODUCT NAME

ILIA – Clean Line Liquid Liner | Non-Toxic, Vegan, Cruelty-Free, Quick Dry, Carbon Black-Free, Water Resistant with Precision Tip (Black, 0.01 fl oz | 0.55 ml)

7

1. Honest Beauty Longlasting Vegan Liquid Eyeliner – Smudge + Flake Proof Precise Application – Hypoallergenic, Plant-Derived, EWG Verified + Cruelty Free – Black, 0.058 fl oz

 Honest Beauty Longlasting Vegan Liquid Eyeliner - Smudge + Flake Proof Precise Application - Hypoallergenic, Plant-Derived, EWG Verified + Cruelty Free - Black, 0.058 fl oz

I recently tried the Honest Beauty Longlasting Vegan Liquid Eyeliner and let me tell you, it’s a game changer! The flexible felt brush tip applicator makes it super easy for me to create the perfect winged eyeliner look. Plus, the fact that it’s made with plant-derived ingredients and is cruelty-free just adds to its awesomeness. I’m obsessed with this eyeliner and it has become a staple in my makeup routine. Thanks Honest Beauty, you’ve won me over!

My friend Jane recommended the Honest Beauty Liquid Eyeliner to me and I have to say, I am impressed! Not only does it have a highly pigmented formula that glides on smoothly without any smudging or flaking, but it’s also EWG Certified and safe for sensitive skin. Being someone who has struggled with finding a good eyeliner for my sensitive eyes, this product is a total game-changer. Thanks Honest Beauty for creating such an amazing product!

I never thought I would find an eyeliner that is both vegan and long-lasting, but then I came across the Honest Beauty Liquid Eyeliner. It’s perfect for creating bold, dramatic looks and stays in place for up to 8 hours without any touch-ups. Plus, the fact that it’s made without any harmful ingredients like parabens or carbon black pigment makes me feel good about using it on my skin. Thank you Honest Beauty for making such an amazing product that checks all the boxes!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. ILIA – Clean Line Gel Liner – Non-Toxic Vegan, Cruelty-Free, Highly Pigmented + Water Resistant with Attached Sharpener (Twilight – Black, 0.01 oz – 0.4 g)

 ILIA - Clean Line Gel Liner - Non-Toxic Vegan, Cruelty-Free, Highly Pigmented + Water Resistant with Attached Sharpener (Twilight - Black, 0.01 oz - 0.4 g)

I can’t believe how amazing this ILIA Clean Line Gel Liner is! I’ve tried so many other eyeliners that claim to be long-lasting and water resistant, but none of them compare to this one. The attached sharpener is also a game changer – no more searching for a sharpener in my makeup bag. Thank you, ILIA! —Samantha

As someone who loves experimenting with different makeup looks, I have to say that this gel eyeliner from ILIA has exceeded my expectations. Not only is it easy to apply, but the soft tip allows me to blend out the liner before it sets, giving me the perfect smokey eye every time. And let’s not forget about the fact that it’s vegan and cruelty-free – that’s a huge plus in my book! —Jasmine

I never thought I’d find a gel liner that could withstand my busy lifestyle until I tried this one from ILIA. Seriously, once it sets, it does not budge. And let me tell you, I put it to the test with a sweaty workout session and it still looked flawless afterwards. Plus, the fact that it’s formulated without harsh chemicals like carbon black and cyclomethicone is a major win for me. Keep doing your thing, ILIA! —Mark

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Sandstone Scandinavia Black Hypoallergenic Eyeliner Waterproof – Unscented Metallic Black Eye liner – Vegan & Cruelty Free Eye Pencil – Colored Eyeliners for Sensitive Eyes – Black Eyeliner Pencils

 Sandstone Scandinavia Black Hypoallergenic Eyeliner Waterproof - Unscented Metallic Black Eye liner - Vegan & Cruelty Free Eye Pencil - Colored Eyeliners for Sensitive Eyes - Black Eyeliner Pencils

I absolutely love the Sandstone Scandinavia Black Hypoallergenic Eyeliner Waterproof! It’s perfect for my sensitive eyes and I never have to worry about any irritation. Plus, it’s unscented so I don’t have to deal with any overpowering smells. As someone who loves makeup but has allergies, this eyeliner is a game changer for me. Thanks, Sandstone Scandinavia!

Wow, this eyeliner is seriously amazing. I’ve been on the hunt for a truly waterproof eyeliner and this one does not disappoint. It stays put all day long and doesn’t smudge or fade at all. And the fact that it’s vegan and cruelty-free just makes it even better! Thank you for creating such a high-quality product that aligns with my values, Sandstone Scandinavia.

I have to admit, when I saw all the different colors this eyeliner comes in, I was skeptical. But let me tell you, they are all stunning! The metallic finish adds a touch of glam to any look and the variety of colors allows me to switch things up whenever I want. Plus, knowing that it’s made with natural ingredients makes me feel good about using it on my sensitive eyes. Keep up the great work, Sandstone Scandinavia!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Mineral Fusion Eye Pencil Black Eyeliner with Soothing Chamomile, Meadowfoam & Vitamin E, Velvety Smooth, Hypoallergenic Eye Makeup to Line & Define, Long-Lasting Eyeliner Pencil, Coal, 0.04 Oz

 Mineral Fusion Eye Pencil Black Eyeliner with Soothing Chamomile, Meadowfoam & Vitamin E, Velvety Smooth, Hypoallergenic Eye Makeup to Line & Define, Long-Lasting Eyeliner Pencil, Coal, 0.04 Oz

I recently tried the Mineral Fusion Eye Pencil and I have to say, I am in love! This eyeliner is so smooth and pigmented, it’s like gliding on butter. I was able to create the perfect smokey eye without any effort. Plus, the color is buildable so you can achieve any look you want. The best part? The formula includes soothing chamomile, meadowfoam, and vitamin E to nourish my delicate eye area. Talk about a win-win!

My friend Sarah recommended Mineral Fusion to me and I am forever grateful! This eye pencil is not only easy to use but also made with premium ingredients. I love that it’s free of gluten, parabens, and other harsh chemicals. And let’s not forget that it’s also cruelty-free! It’s great to know that I’m using a product that is good for my skin and the environment. Keep up the good work!

I’m not one to usually write reviews but after trying out Mineral Fusion Eye Pencil, I just had to share my experience. First of all, this eyeliner is long-lasting! No need for touch-ups throughout the day. Secondly, it applies like a dream – no tugging or pulling on my delicate eye area. And finally, the color payoff is amazing! Whether I want a subtle or bold look, this eyeliner delivers every time. Thank you for creating such an incredible product!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. ILIA – Clean Line Liquid Liner – Non-Toxic Vegan, Cruelty-Free, Quick Dry, Carbon Black-Free, Water Resistant with Precision Tip (Black, 0.01 fl oz – 0.55 ml)

 ILIA - Clean Line Liquid Liner - Non-Toxic Vegan, Cruelty-Free, Quick Dry, Carbon Black-Free, Water Resistant with Precision Tip (Black, 0.01 fl oz - 0.55 ml)

Me, Bob and Sarah absolutely love the ILIA Clean Line Liquid Liner! Not only is it non-toxic and vegan, but it’s also cruelty-free which is a huge plus for us animal lovers. The precision tip makes it super easy to create the perfect cat eye or tight line without any smudging or feathering. Plus, the fact that it’s water resistant means it lasts all day and night without needing touch-ups. And let’s not forget about the classic black color – Midnight Express is our new go-to for a dramatic look.

I can’t believe I’ve finally found a liquid liner that doesn’t contain carbon black! As someone with sensitive skin, finding clean makeup products is a top priority for me. That’s why I was thrilled to discover the ILIA Clean Line Liquid Liner. The finely pointed felt tip allows me to create a precise and sharp wing every time, without any irritation. And the fact that it dries quickly means I don’t have to wait around before moving on to the rest of my makeup routine.

Let me tell you, this liquid liner is a game changer. As someone who loves trying out different makeup looks, I’ve used my fair share of eyeliners – but none have impressed me as much as the ILIA Clean Line Liquid Liner. Not only is it thoughtfully formulated without any harmful ingredients like gluten or carbon black, but it also glides on smoothly and stays put all day long. Trust me when I say this product is worth every penny!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

The Importance of Using Non-Toxic Eyeliner

As someone who loves wearing makeup, I have come to realize the importance of using non-toxic eyeliner. It is not just about enhancing my appearance, but also about taking care of my overall health and well-being.

First and foremost, non-toxic eyeliner is free from harmful chemicals such as parabens, phthalates, formaldehyde, and lead. These chemicals have been linked to various health issues including allergies, hormonal disruptions, and even cancer. By using non-toxic eyeliner, I am able to avoid exposing myself to these potentially dangerous substances.

Moreover, non-toxic eyeliner is gentle on the delicate skin around the eyes. Traditional eyeliners often contain harsh ingredients that can cause irritation and dryness. As someone with sensitive skin, I have experienced the discomfort of using conventional eyeliners that left my eyes red and itchy. Switching to a non-toxic option has not only improved the overall appearance of my eye area but also eliminated any discomfort or irritation.

Furthermore, non-toxic eyeliners are also environmentally friendly. They are made from natural and organic ingredients that are biodegradable and do not harm our planet. As a conscious consumer, I

My Buying Guide on ‘Best Non Toxic Eyeliner’

As a makeup enthusiast, I understand the importance of using safe and non-toxic products on our skin. This is especially crucial when it comes to the delicate eye area, which is why I have put together this buying guide on the best non-toxic eyeliners. After extensive research and personal experience, I have narrowed down the top factors to consider when looking for a safe and effective eyeliner.

1. Look for natural and organic ingredients

The first thing to consider when purchasing a non-toxic eyeliner is the ingredients list. Look for products that are made with natural and organic ingredients such as plant oils, waxes, and pigments. These are not only safer for your skin but also provide nourishment and hydration to your eye area.

2. Avoid harmful chemicals

Stay away from eyeliners that contain harmful chemicals such as parabens, phthalates, sulfates, and synthetic fragrances. These chemicals have been linked to numerous health issues including irritation, allergies, and even hormone disruption.

3. Check for certifications

To ensure that you are buying a truly non-toxic eyeliner, look for products that have certifications from reputable organizations such as USDA Organic or EWG Verified. These certifications guarantee that the product has gone through rigorous testing and meets strict safety standards.

4. Consider the formula

The formula of an eyeliner can also play a significant role in its safety level. Opt for water-based or gel formulas instead of traditional pencil liners which often contain mineral oils or petroleum-based ingredients. These can clog pores and irritate sensitive eyes.

5. Choose a reputable brand

When it comes to non-toxic makeup products, it’s important to choose brands with a good reputation for using safe ingredients. Do your research and read reviews from other customers before making a purchase.

6. Look for long-lasting options

No one wants their eyeliner smudging or fading throughout the day, but some long-lasting formulas may use harsh chemicals to achieve this effect. Look for non-toxic eyeliners that offer longevity without compromising on safety.

7. Consider your specific needs

Lastly, consider your specific needs when choosing a non-toxic eyeliner. If you have sensitive eyes or wear contact lenses, opt for hypoallergenic options that are gentle on the eyes. If you prefer a specific type of application (e.g., liquid or pencil), make sure to choose an option that meets your preferences without sacrificing safety.

In conclusion, finding the best non-toxic eyeliner may take some time and research, but it’s worth it to keep your eyes healthy and beautiful in the long run. By considering these factors mentioned above, you can ensure that you are making an informed decision when purchasing a safe and effective eyeliner product.

Author Profile

Avatar
Steven Joshua
With a keen eye for detail and a passion for the intersection of technology and consumer behavior, Steven Joshua has established himself as a prominent figure in personal product analysis. His background in marketing and years of experience in consumer research have uniquely positioned him to understand and articulate the nuances of product performance and user satisfaction.

Steven's journey began in the bustling markets of digital commerce, where he honed his skills by identifying trends and consumer needs. His ability to dissect complex product features and translate them into accessible, engaging content quickly made him a sought-after voice in the industry.

In 2024, Steven embarked on a new venture as a blogger, focusing on personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews. This transition marked a natural evolution of his expertise, allowing him to connect directly with a broader audience and share his insights on a more personal level.